Larry Hunter – Idaho State ABA House of Delegates
The annual meeting returned to Chicago, the headquarters of the ABA and, of course, the home of President Obama. Besides the traditional welcome from the governor and mayor of the host state and city, President Obama sent his greetings via a taped presentation in which he acknowledged the role of the ABA in promoting the rule of law. It was the first greeting from a sitting president in many years.
Besides President Obama, recently retired associate Justice Souter addressed the assembled guests at the opening ceremonies. Justice Souter directed his remarks to the dearth of secondary instruction in the American public school system on the American governmental system – civics. Many, if not most, public school systems have dropped civics instruction at the high school level – including the school districts of Idaho. This had led to a distressing lack of knowledge and seeming disinterest in the American populace about how and why our system works. Checks and balances may as well be what you do to your car tires rather than the interaction of the three branches of government.
Indeed, many people forget the role that an independent judiciary plays in that system of checks and balances. Periodically, the role of the justice system hits the news, such as during Justice Sotomayor’s confirmation hearings. However, even that brief illumination of the courts often demonstrates the lack of understandingof the court’s role – even from members of the Senate who confirm the appointment of federal judges. Amongst the general populace, surveys reveal that more Americans can name a judge on American Idol than a justice of the Supreme Court. The ABA has recently emphasized the need for each of us, as attorneys and officers of the court, to try to work for increased civic education – preferably in the high school, but at least through adult education opportunities, such as the Citizen Law Academy that we have in Idaho.
For the first time in a number of years, Idaho’s delegation was without Allyn Dingel’s presence. Not only we Idahoans, but many others in the House of Delegates, expressed their sadness at Allyn’s untimely passing. He will be missed at many levels.
At the end of the session, Tim Hopkins of Idaho Falls became a member of the Board of Governors. Without going into great detail about the ABA’s governance, suffice it to say that Idaho has a right to a seat on the Board of Governors only once every 12 years. Tim will have a positive and significant influence in that body for the next three years. The Idaho delegation in the House of Delegates attending this meeting was Larry Hunter, the new state delegate, and Craig Meadows, who served as the state bar delegate. Tim joined us and is an ex officio member of the House as a member of the Board of Governors. Eugene Thomas is a lifetime member of the House as a former chair of the House and president of the ABA. Four is about as many as we can hope for unless someone rises through the ranks of a section to become a section delegate or a woman or minority delegate at large.
With regard to the other offices of the organization, Carolyn Lamm of Washington D.C. became the new president of the organization with Stephen Zack of Miami as president-elect and Bill Robinson of Kentucky as president-elect designee. There will be further elections at the February meeting for chairman of the House of Delegates and secretary and treasurer of the organization.
With regard to the substantive measures considered by the House, there were several considered, but none that evoked the debate as did the screening amendment to the Rules of Professional Conduct. There was difference of opinion between the Litigation Section and the Family Law Section on a recommendation regarding the representation of children in abuse and neglect scenarios. After multiple emails supporting one or the other, the resolution was withdrawn to see if a consensus could be reached. We will see it again in October.
Contrary to some reports, the House did not endorse same sex marriage. But it did pass a resolution recommending that couples whose same sex union was legally sanctioned by the state they lived in be eligible for federal benefits as a married couple. It remains to be seen whether a resolution to recognize same sex marriage will be considered by the House.
There were additional resolutions, 43 in all, which dealt with everything from patent law to paralegals. A summary of actions taken is available on the ABA website. As a whimsical conclusion to this report, it should be reported that the Senior Lawyers Division withdrew its resolution changing the name of the group to the Elder Law and Experienced Lawyers Division. Apparently, practicality won out over political correctness.
About the Author
Larry Hunter serves as the Idaho State Delegate to the American Bar Association House of Delegates. He is a partner with Moffatt, Thomas, Barrett, Rock and Fields in Boise. His practice includes general and commercial litigation, administrative law, and alternative dispute resolution. He is a past president of the Idaho State Bar. He received his J.D. from Northwestern University School of Law. He has an A.B. from Harvard University (cum laude). Contact information for Larry is: (208) 345-2000, or lch@moffatt.com.
Reprinted with permission from The Advocate, official publication of the Idaho State Bar, vol. 52, issue 10, page 44, October, 2009.